English | Português | Français | Español | Русский | 中文 | العربية
WSIS Knowledge Communities
Remember me | Lost password

You are viewing this page as a non-logged user. Login to see the full content and functionality. Do not have an account? Click here to register to become a member of the platform.

The OER university is a virtual collaboration of like-minded institutions committed to creating pathways for OER learners to gain credible qualifications through the formal education system.

Share |
Discussions > An opportunity to get licensing right and respecting freedom of choice!

Wayne Mackintosh
445 days ago

Hi Everyone,

We have a great opportuntiy to get licensing choices right and respecting freedom of choice.

Abel wrote:

"In a few short months we will also have CC BY SA NC licensing working steadily upwards to full CC BY licensing. You can imagine how I have to work within UNESCO's steady-as-she-goes processes."

I appreciate the challenges of intellectual property policies within large international agencies. However, UNESCO does not own the intellectual property of the contributions to the OER platform. UNESCO, could in terms of its conditions of service state that contributions are licensed under a CC-BY-SA-NC license but I don't think such an approach is aligned with the principles of a modern democracy where we respect freedom of choice. Moreover, it may not be legally possible for some contributors to participate on the OER platform under those conditions.

In my own context, as a matter of policy, I would not legally be able to participate on a site which does not use free cultural works appoved licenses (CC-BY, CC-BY-SA) or works dedicated to the public domain. Moreover, the core principles of engagement of the OER university concept have committed to releasing outputs under free cultural works approved licenses.

I would recommend the following solution:

  • Individual contributors should have the freedom to assign the license of their choice to their contributions by adding a footnote to their posts specifying the license of their contributions.
  • In time, UNESCO could develop the code with an option to specify a CC license for their posts -- this would also be a valuable contribution to the elgg community.

Given the OER Foundation's committment to free cultural works licensing -- we would not be able to host discussions for the OER university on a site which uses a CC-BY-SA-NC license :-(. Let's respect the IP choices of individual users and allow them to specify how their IP is used. UNESCO of course is free to license its creative works under their chosen license.

To assist with internal discussions, there are a few precidents which may be useful:

  • The UNESCO OER wiki has already used a free culural works approved license (CC-BY-SA) 
  • UNV has already waived their standard licensing provisions for the OER FOundation giving us permission to post to their site under a CC-BY-SA license (so an example of a UN agency making exceptions.)
  • Follow the lead of the New Zealand Government Open Access Licensing (NZGOAL) framework passed by Cabinet where state agencies are required to release copyright which may be of interest for reuse under the "most open of licensing terms within NZGOAL – the Creative Commons Attribution (BY) licence".

Hope this helps --- If you need any help in discussing licensing alternatives, please feel free to contact the OER Foundation. Consider this a free gift to building a sustainable OER ecosystem :-).

 

Abel Caine
444 days ago

Hi Wayne, I'm going to reply to this on the parent OER Community so that all 900 members :) can contribute.

Cheers,
Abel